CQD Spotlight features questions and answers from NECA and ELECTRICAL CONTRACTOR’s Code Question of the Day program. Whether you’re a seasoned contractor, an apprentice or simply a National Electrical Code enthusiast, you’ll gain knowledge with a nod to the legacy of Charles M. “Charlie” Trout, a true NEC legend
From the archives—March 30, 2026
A garbage disposal is considered an appliance and covered by Article 422. Where a disposal is the largest motor load in a dwelling, would Part II of Article 120 require an additional 25% of the motor nameplate FLA to be included in the calculation?
Your logic is correct, if the disposal is the largest motor load on that branch circuit. 120.11(A) states that for a branch circuit supplying fastened-in-place motor loads greater than 1/8 hp in combination with other loads, the total calculated load must be 125% of the motor plus the other loads. Most household disposals are ½ or ¾ hp.
Also, by including the 25% adjustment, this aligns with NEC 430.24, which is referenced in 120.11.
From the archives—June 12, 2026
Can a demand factor be applied to commercial cooking equipment when sizing a feeder? I have a kitchen with 250 kilowatts (kW) of connected cooking load across multiple appliances and the calculation seems high.
Yes, a demand factor can be applied. Table 120.56 provides demand factors for commercial cooking equipment. For example, a feeder for four or more appliances has a permitted demand factor of 80%, reducing your 250-kW connected load to 200 kW for feeder sizing. The table covers commercial cooking equipment, dishwasher booster heaters, water heaters and “other kitchen equipment” as specified in the parent text. The demand factors for commercial equipment are higher than for those in dwelling units since the equipment is anticipated to be operated consistently and for longer periods of time.
From the archives—Oct. 10, 20245
Here in New York state, we are still on the 2017 NEC. We are doing a load calculation for a new school. The 2017 edition of Table 220.12 applies a general calculated load for schools at 3 VA/ft². The 2023 edition of the table applies a calculated load of 1½ VA/ft². I believe this change is because of the technical advances that have happened since before the 2017 edition (and 2020 for that matter) went into print. Today, in 2024, we are building with the latest technical advantages, e.g., LED lighting, split HVAC systems, etc. Since we are employing these more technically advanced, energy-efficient systems, I would venture to say that the use of 1½ VA/ft² would be a reasonable calculation method, albeit not the present code. What is your opinion on this?
You are correct, Table 220.12 of the 2017 NEC requires a general lighting load of 3 VA/ft2, whereas Table 220.42 of the 2023 NEC only requires a 1.5 VA/ft2. This reduction is a result of the advancements in improved lighting efficiency.
Most jurisdictions have some type of “special permission or variance” process for these types of situations. This is a great example of the benefit to adopting the most recent edition of the NEC. Best to check with the AHJ to see what the process is for getting special permission or variance permitting the application of the updated rule.
From the archives—July 11, 2025
I’m working on a design-build electrical installation for a 107-room extended-stay hotel. It has four stories, type 5 construction. I have made that determination since each unit has fixed provisions for cooking, sleeping and sanitation. I’m not clear if 230.79(C) applies as this is a multifamily building, not a one-family dwelling. The calculated loads for the units range from 50A to 75A depending on the unit, with the vast majority at 50A. Does 230.79(C) apply? It not, what code dictates if a panel is required?
NEC 230.79(C) would not apply in this case. NEC 230.79(C) is specific to services for one- and two-family dwellings. While you have numerous dwelling units in this building, the supply to the units are feeders and not services.
NEC 240.24(B) would require the occupant to have access to the branch circuit overcurrent protective devices supplying the dwelling unit. This is most easily achieved by having a panel in each unit. NEC 240.24(B)(2) would not apply in this case since each unit has permanent provisions for cooking. NEC 240.24(B)(1) would apply. The occupant would not be required to have access to the feeder overcurrent device.
Get more out of this discussion through the CQD Spotlight podcast.