In 1980, the torch-bearing, uplifted right arm of the Statue of Liberty was undetectably in danger of breaking off.
Although she may outwardly appear as solid as any historic bronze or granite sculpture in the middle of any American town, the Statue of Liberty is essentially hollow. She creates the illusion of solidity with an outer shell of 300 dovetailed copper panels that were pounded into their individual shapes with wooden mallets wielded by a few hundred French artisans in Paris nearly one and a half centuries ago.
Those 300 sculpted copper panels were fitted together and secured by more than 1,800 precisely shaped straps of iron framework, which were connected to an armature rising through the middle of her body. Her 19th century designers fully anticipated that Lady Liberty would gently sway with the breezes above the New York harbor. But they did not recognize how a slightly misaligned spike in her crown would inevitably poke and pierce the bicep of her uplifted right arm.
Were it not for a newsworthy incident in which two political protesters ascended the outside of the statue in May 1980 using 9-inch-diameter suction cups and mountaineering equipment, the full extent of her physical ailments might never have been known before her 100th birthday celebration in 1986.
The Statue of Liberty was originally envisioned by a small group of French idealists as a gift from the French people to celebrate the outcome of the American Civil War. Although they had hoped to do so in 1876, slow fundraising delayed their progress. Their dreams were fulfilled when La Liberté Éclairant le Monde (that’s her real name: Liberty Lighting the World) was officially dedicated 10 years later on Oct. 28, 1886.
In some of her little-known history, we find great takeaways for electrical service and maintenance contractors today and into the future.
Takeaway No. 1: Construction prefabrication is like commercial aviation, in that landing as scheduled is a key performance indicator. Figuratively speaking, it requires on-time performance and close coordination between the “airline” and the “airport” to reap the benefits of prefabrication.
With this artistic installation, Parisians managed the longest-running prefabrication effort in modern history, begun in 1875 and completed in 1884.
Americans were responsible for designing and building the massive base on which Lady Liberty has stood for 140 years. Although the ship carrying all her prefabricated components arrived in June 1885, construction of the base was not completed until April 1886.
Takeaway No. 2: Constantly shifting the management of maintenance can be worse than no maintenance at all. The statue was a monument to mismanaged maintenance, and some maintenance activities provably worsened the unseen deterioration of this national treasure.
Over its 140-year history, it has suffered from a succession of hand-offs from one federal agency to the next. There were many years in which no one from the agency that was supposed to be overseeing it was designated to be in charge. For decades, Lady Liberty suffered from a lack of consistency in regular maintenance.
Its copper panels fastened to its iron framework, coupled with the salt, moisture and breeze from New York Harbor, eventually turned the statue into one big electric battery, producing negligible voltage but steadily corroding the iron.
Gustave Eiffel had expressly taken great care to isolate the 31 tons of copper panels from the 125 tons of iron framework with shellac-soaked asbestos pads at every point of contact. But the march of time and the consequences of neglect were too much to overcome.
Takeaway No. 3: Without good diagnostics, maintenance is mostly guesswork. Like maintenance, diagnostics are easy to avoid.
Even after the arrival of a maintenance-conscious superintendent named David L. Moffitt in 1977, the true condition of the statue was not fully appreciated. It was only after the climbing protesters episode in 1980 produced concern about the physical condition of the statue that Moffitt called in the engineering firm under contract with the park service for an assessment. They looked around and found nothing to worry about. Luckily, he got help from a qualified team of French and American experts who employed appropriate scientific analysis—and found plenty to worry about.
In a renovation campaign costing hundreds of millions of dollars, Lady Liberty was therefore rejuvenated in time for her hundredth birthday.
Takeaway No. 4: Be open to lessons from what’s new to you. While Lady Liberty has been around a long time, electrical contracting actually arrived in New York City well before she did. Two former employees of Thomas Edison named Hatzel and Buehler had their eponymous firm up and running in 1884. But that doesn’t mean there wasn’t plenty to learn from that shiny new installation—and the same is true today.
stock.adobe.com/VASYL
About The Author
MCCOY is Beliveau professor in the Dept. of Building Construction, associate director of the Myers-Lawson School of Construction and director of the Virginia Center for Housing Research at Virginia Tech. Contact him at [email protected].
SARGENT heads Great Service Forums℠, which offers networking opportunities, business development and professional education to its membership of service-oriented contractors. Email him at [email protected].